Geografie 2022, 127, 319-340

Critical elements in determining tourism routes: a systematic literature review

Muhammad Anas Khairul AnuarID, Azizan MarzukiID

Universiti Sains Malaysia, School of Housing, Building and Planning, Penang, Malaysia

Received February 2022
Accepted June 2022


1. ANTONSON, H., JACOBSEN, J.K.S. (2014): Tourism development strategy or just brown signage? Comparing road administration policies and designation procedures for official tourism routes in two Scandinavian countries. Land Use Policy, 36, 342−350. <>
2. ARSLAN, M. (2013): Ancient routes, new destinations: Roman Road Via Sebaste as a thematic cultural route. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 4, 10, 660−665.
3. AUKLAND, K. (2017): Pilgrimage expansion through tourism in contemporary India: the development and promotion of a Hindu pilgrimage circuit. Journal of Contemporary Religion, 32, 2, 283−298. <>
4. BAMBI, G., IACOBELLI, S., ROSSI, G., PELLEGRINI, P., BARBARI, M. (2019): Rural tourism to promote territories along the ancient roads of communication: Case study of the rediscovery of the St. Francis’s ways between Florence and LA Verna. European Countryside, 11, 3, 462−474. <>
5. BARROCO, C., AMARO, S. (2020): Examining the progress of the Dão wine route wineries’ websites. Revista Turismo & Desenvolvimento, 33, 29−40.
6. BATES, J., BEST, P., MCQUILKIN, J., TAYLOR, B. (2017): Will web search engines replace bibliographic databases in the systematic identification of research? J. Acad. Librariansh, 43, 1, 8−17. <>
7. BOŽIĆ, S., TOMIĆ, N. (2016): Developing the Cultural Route Evaluation Model (CREM) and its application on the Trail of Roman Emperors, Serbia. Tourism Management Perspectives, 17, 26−35. <>
8. BREIBY, M.A., SLÅTTEN, T. (2018): The role of aesthetic experiential qualities for tourist satisfaction and loyalty. International Journal of Culture, Tourism, and Hospitality Research, 12, 1, 1−14. <>
9. BRIEDENHANN, J., WICKENS, E. (2004): Tourism routes as a tool for the economic development of rural areas-vibrant hope or impossible dream? Tourism Management, 25, 1, 71−79. <>
10. CAMPRUBÍ, R., GALÍ, N. (2015): An exploratory analysis of wineries websites functionality: The case of the doq priorat route-wineries. Boletin de La Asociacion de Geografos Espanoles, 68, 159−176.
11. CARTAN, G., CARSON, D. (2009): Engagement local en développementéconomique et collaboration le long de la route australienne de gunbarrel. Tourism Geographies, 11, 2, 169−186. <>
12. CAVA JIMÉNEZ, J.A., DE LA TORRE, M.G.M. V., ROJAS, R.H. (2019): Analysis of the tourism demand for Iberian ham routes in Andalusia (Southern Spain): Tourist profile. Sustainability, 11, 16, 4278. <>
13. DAYOUB, B., YANG, P., DAYOUB, A., OMRAN, S., LI, H. (2020): The role of cultural routes in sustainable tourism development: A case study of Syria’s spiritual route. International Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning, 15, 6, 865−874. <>
14. DE LA TORRE, G.M.V., FERNÁNDEZ, E.M., PÉREZ NARANJO, L.M. (2014): Gastronomic tourism protected designations of origin and rural development in Andalusia: Present situation. Boletin de La Asociacion de Geografos Espanoles, 65, 437−439.
15. DENSTADLI, J.M., JACOBSEN, J.K.S. (2011): The long and winding roads: Perceived quality of scenic tourism routes. Tourism Management, 32, 4, 780−789. <>
16. FJELSTUL, J., FYALL, A. (2015): Sustainable drive tourism: a catalyst for change. International Journal of Tourism Research, 17, 5, 460−471. <>
17. FRASH, R.E., BLOSE, J.E., SMITH, W.W., SCHERHAG, K. (2018): A multidisciplinary marketing profile of motorcycle tourists: Explores escaping routine to find flow on scenic routes. Tourism Recreation Research, 43, 4, 432−444. <>
18. FYALL, A., TEMPLETON, A.J., FJLESTUL, J., SONMEZ, S. (2016): The Emergence of Green Drive Tourism: A Comparative Study of Existing Drive Tourism Routes. Travel and Tourism Research Association: Advancing Tourism Research Globally, 6,
19. GREYSON, D., RAFFERTY, E., SLATER, L., MACDONALD, N., BETTINGER, J.A., DUBÉ, È., MACDONALD, S.E. (2019): Systematic review searches must be systematic, comprehensive, and transparent: a critique of Perman et al. BMC Public Health, 19, 1, 1−6. <>
20. GUSENBAUER, M., HADDAWAY, N.R. (2020): Which academic search systems are suitable for systematic reviews or meta-analyses? Evaluating retrieval qualities of Google Scholar, PubMed, and 26 other resources. Res. Synth. Methods, 11, 2, 181−217. <>
21. HADDAWAY, N.R., MACURA. B., WHALEY. P., PULLIN, A.S. (2018): ROSES RepOrting standards for Systematic Evidence Syntheses: Pro forma, flow-diagram and descriptive summary of the plan and conduct of environmental systematic reviews and systematic maps. Environmental Evidence, 7, 1, 1−8.
22. HARDY, A. (2003): An investigation into the key factors necessary for the development of iconic touring routes. Journal of Vacation Marketing, 9, 4, 314−330. <>
23. HEMME, D. (2005): Landscape, fairies and identity: Experience on the backstage of the fairy tale route. Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, 3, 2, 71−87. <>
24. HIGGINS, J.P.T., ALTMAN, D.G., GOTZSCHE, P.C., JUNI, P., MOHER, D., OXMAN, A.D., SAVOVIC, J., SCHULZ, K.F., WEEKS, L., STERNE, J.A.C. (2011): The Cochrane collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ, 343, 1−9. <>
25. HORÁK, M., KOZUMPLÍKOVÁ, A., SOMERLÍKOVÁ, K., LORENCOVÁ, H., LAMPARTOVÁ, I. (2015): Religious Tourism in the South-Moravian and Zlín Regions: Proposal for Three New Pilgrimage Routes. European Countryside, 7, 3, 167−178. <>
26. ISPAS, A., CONSTANTIN, C.P., CANDREA, A.N. (2015): An examination of visitors’ interest in tourist cards and cultural routes in the case of a Romanian destination. Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences, 46, 10, 107−125.
27. JACOBSEN, J.K.S. (2011): Unike natur- og kjøreopplevelser: trafikantvurderinger av Nasjonale turistveger. Transportøkonomisk institutt (TØI), Oslo, 1−31.
28. LOURENS, M. (2007): Route tourism: A roadmap for successful destinations and local economic development. Development Southern Africa, 24, 3, 475−490. <>
29. MACLEOD, N. (2016): Self-guided trails – A route to more responsible tourism? Tourism Recreation Research, 41, 2, 134−144. <>
30. MACLEOD, N. (2017): The role of trails in the creation of tourist space. Journal of Heritage Tourism, 12, 5, 423−430. <>
31. MALLET, R., HAGEN-ZANKER, J., SLATER, R., DUVENDACK, M. (2012): The benefits and challenges of using systematic reviews in international development research. Journal of Development Effectiveness, 4, 3, 445−455. <>
32. MARSCHALL, S. (2012): Sustainable heritage tourism: The Inanda Heritage Route and the 2010 FIFA World Cup. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 20, 5, 721−736. <>
33. MAURIZIO, M., PATTANARO, G. (2012). An end-user development architecture for routebased tourism in a web 2.0 environment. E-Review of Tourism Research, 10, 3, 26−30.
34. MEYER, D. (2004): Tourism routes and gateways: key issues for the development of tourism routes and gateways and their potential for Pro-Poor Tourism. Discussion Paper. Overseas Development Institute.
35. MOHER, D., LIBERATI, A., TETZLAFF, J., ALTMAN, D.G. (2009): Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ, 339, b2535. <>
36. MOULIN, C., BONIFACE, P. (2001): Routeing heritage for tourism: Making heritage and cultural tourism networks for socioeconomic development. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 7, 3, 237−248. <>
37. MUTANA, S., MUKWADA, G. (2017): An exploratory assessment of significant tourism sustainability indicators for a montane-based route in the Drakensberg Mountains. Sustainability, 9, 7, 1202. <>
38. MUTANA, S., MUKWADA, G. (2020): Can mountain route tourism work for the poor? Exploring worldviews from Maluti Route in the Drakensberg Region of South Africa. Tourism and Hospitality Research, 20, 1, 18−30. <>
39. NEMETH, D.J., CHE, D. (2013): Alternative tourism geographies: leveraging the ironic case of Pennsylvania’s Route 666 for economic development. Applied Geography, 45, 109−118. <>
40. NOWERS, R., DE VILLIERS, E., MYBURGH, A. (2002): Agricultural theme routes as a diversification strategy: the western cape wine routes case study. Agrekon, 41, 2, 195−209. <>
41. OIKONOMOPOULOU, E., DELEGOU, E.T., SAYAS, J., MOROPOULOU, A. (2017): An innovative approach to the protection of cultural heritage: The case of cultural routes in Chios Island, Greece. Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, 14, 742−757.
42. OLSEN, M. (2003): Tourism themed routes: A Q ueensland perspective. Journal of Vacation Marketing, 9, 4, 331−341. <>
43. PLUMMER, R., TELFER, D., HASHIMOTO, A. (2006): The rise and fall of the Waterloo- Wellington Ale Trail: A study of collaboration within the tourism industry. Current Issues in Tourism, 9, 3, 191−205. <>
44. PROOS, E., HATTINGH, J. (2020): Advancing heritage tourism in the central Karoo: The South African War Battlefields Route. Development Southern Africa, 37, 4, 678−693. <>
45. PROOS, E., KOKT, D., HATTINGH, J.L. (2017): Marketing and management effectiveness of free state section of maloti Drakensberg route. South African Journal for Research in Sport, Physical Education and Recreation, 39, 1, 135−147.
46. QIU, H., HSU, C., LI, M., SHU, B. (2018): Self-drive tourism attributes influence on satisfaction and behavioural intention. Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research, 23, 4, 395−407. <>
47. RAMSEY, D., EVERITT, J. (2007): Route-based tourism development and the “Turkey trail” in Manitoba, Canada. Prairie Forum, 32, 1, 87−110.
48. RAMUKUMBA, T. (2019): Analysing tourism stakeholders’ perceptions of the attractiveness and competitiveness of the Garden Route as a tourist destination. African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure, 8, 1, 1−9.
49. ROGERSON, C.M. (2007): Tourism Routes as Vehicles for Local Economic Development in South Africa: The Example of the Magaliesberg Meander. Urban Forum, 18, 2, 49−68. <>
50. ROY, N., GRETZEL, U. (2020): Themed route marketing in India. Anatolia, 31, 2, 304−315. <>
51. SHIH, H.Y. (2006): Network characteristics of drive tourism destinations: An application of network analysis in tourism. Tourism Management, 27, 5, 1029−1039. <>
52. SHAFFRIL, H.A.M., ABU SAMAH, A., SAMSUDDIN, S.F., ALI, Z. (2019): Mirror-mirror on the wall, what climate change adaptation strategies are practiced by the Asian’s fishermen of all? Journal of Cleaner Production, 232, 104−117. <>
53. SIERRA-CORREA, P.C., CANTERA-KINTZ, J.R. (2015): Ecosystem-based adaptation for improving coastal planning for sea-level rise: A systematic review for mangrove coasts. Marine Policy, 51, 385−393. <>
54. SNOWBALL, J.D., COURTNEY, S. (2010): Cultural heritage routes in South Africa: Effective tools for heritage conservation and local economic development? Development Southern Africa, 27, 4, 563−576. <>
55. TELFER, D.J. (2001a): From a Wine Tourism Village to a Regional Wine Route: An Investigation of the Competitive Advantage of Embedded Clusters in Niagara, Canada. Tourism Recreation Research, 26, 2, 23−33. <>
56. TELFER, D.J. (2001b): Strategic alliances along the Niagara Wine Route. Tourism Management, 22, 1, 21−30. <>
57. TELFER, D.J. (2015): From a wine tourism village to a regional wine route: an investigation of the competitive advantage of embedded clusters in Niagara, Canada. Tourism Recreation Research, 26, 23−33. <>
58. TIMOTHY, D.J. (2014): Contemporary cultural heritage and tourism: Development issues and emerging trends. Public Archaeology, 13, 1−3, 30–47. <>
59. TIMOTHY, D., BOYD, S. (2015): Tourism and Trails: Cultural, Ecological and Management Issues. Bristol, Blue Ridge Summit: Channel View Publications.
60. TKACZYNSKI, A., RUNDLE-THIELE, S. (2019): Is destination marketing missing the mark? A Fraser Coast segmentation analysis. Journal of Destination Marketing and Management, 12, 4, 12−14. <>
61. TRIŠIĆ, I., ŠTETIĆ, S., PRIVITERA, D., NEDELCU, A. (2020): Wine routes in Vojvodina Province, Northern Serbia: A tool for sustainable tourism development. Sustainability, 12, 1, 82. <>
62. ZAKARIYA, K., IBRAHIM, P.H., WAHAB, N.A.A. (2019). Conceptual framework of rural landscape character assessment to guide tourism development in rural areas. Journal of Construction in Developing Countries, 24, 1, 85−99. <>
63. WIDAWSKI, K., OLEŚNIEWICZ, P. (2019): Thematic tourist trails: Sustainability assessment methodology. The case of a land flowing with milk and honey. Sustainability, 11, 14, 3841. <>
64. XIAO, Y., WATSON, M. (2019): Guidance on conducting a systematic literature review. Journal of Planning Education, 39, 1, 93−112. <>
65. XU, S., LEUNG, Y.F., BARBIERI, C. (2016): Characterising Themed Touring Routes: A Geospatial and Tourism Evaluation of Wine Trails. Tourism Planning and Development, 13, 2, 168−184. <>
66. ZDON-KORZENIOWSKA, M., NOVIELLO, M. (2019): The Wooden Architecture Route is an example of a regional tourism product in Poland. Sustainability, 11, 18, 5128. <>
67. ZHENG, M.C. (2015): How a map with a tour route recommendation promotes circuitous tourism. Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering, 14, 2, 363−370. <>
68. ZILLINGER, M. (2007): Tourist Routes: A time-geographical approach on German car-tourists in Sweden. Tourism Geographies, 9, 1, 64−83. <>
69. ZOOMERS, A. (2008): Global travelling along the Inca route: Is international tourism beneficial for local development? European Planning Studies, 16, 7, 971−983. <>
70. ZULKIFLI, N.H., IBRAHIM, P.H., ZAKARIYA, K. (2020): Integration of rural landscape characters of the Pahang-Terengganu coastal route for tourism route planning. Alam Cipta, 13, 1, 6−13.
front cover

ISSN 1212-0014 (Print) ISSN 2571-421X (Online)