Geografie 2018, 123, 353-378

Eye-tracking analysis of the influence of relief shading on finding labels on tourist maps

Stanislav Popelka

Palacký University Olomouc, Faculty of Science, Department of Geoinformatics, Czechia

Received November 2017
Accepted June 2018


1. ANDRIENKO, G., ANDRIENKO, N., BURCH, M., WEISKOPF, D. (2012): Visual Analytics Methodology for Eye Movement Studies. IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 18, 12, 2889–2898. <>
2. BERNABÉ-POVEDA, M. A., SÁNCHEZ-ORTEGA, I., ÇÖLTEKIN, A. (2011): Techniques for Highlighting Relief on Orthoimaginery. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 21, 346–352. <>
3. BILAND, J., ÇÖLTEKIN, A. (2016): An empirical assessment of the impact of the light direction on the relief inversion effect in shaded relief maps: NNW is better than NW. Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 1–15.
4. BRODERSEN, L., ANDERSEN, H.H., WEBER, S. (2002): Applying eye-movement tracking for the study of map perception and map design. Copenhagen: National Survey and Cadastre.
5. BRYCHTOVÁ, A., COLTEKIN, A. (2014): An Empirical User Study for Measuring the Influence of Colour Distance and Font Size in Map Reading Using Eye Tracking. The Cartographic Journal, 1–11.
6. BRYCHTOVÁ, A., PÁSZTO, V., MAREK, L., PÁNEK, J. (2013): Web-design evaluation of the crisis map of the Czech Republic using eye-tracking. Paper presented at the International Multidisciplinary Scientific GeoConference: SGEM: Surveying Geology & mining Ecology Management, Albena, Bulgaria.
7. BURIAN, J., ŠŤÁVOVÁ, Z. (2009): Kartografické a geoinformatické chyby v územních plánech. Geografie, 114, 3, 179–191.
8. CASTNER, H.W., WHEATE, R. (1979): Re-assessing the role played by shaded relief in topographic scale maps. The Cartographic Journal, 16, 2, 77–85. <>
9. COLTEKIN, A., DEMSAR, U., BRYCHTOVÁ, A., VANDROL, J. (2014): Eye-hand coordination during visual search on geographic displays. Paper presented at the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research (ET4S 2014), Vienna, Austria.
10. COLTEKIN, A., HEIL, B., GARLANDINI, S., FABRIKANT, S.I. (2009): Evaluating the effectiveness of interactive map interface designs: a case study integrating usability metrics with eye-movement analysis. Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 36, 1, 5–17. <>
11. DELUCIA, A. (1972): The effect of shaded relief on map information accessibility. The Cartographic Journal, 9, 1, 14–18. <>
12. DUŠEK, R., MIŘIJOVSKÝ, J. (2009): Visualization of geospatial data: chaos in the dimensions. Geografie, 114, 3, 169–178.
13. Eye-tracking Group at Department of Geoinformatics Palacký University in Olomouc, Czech Republic. Olomouc 2012–2015, (15. 9. 2018).
14. FABRIKANT, S.I., REBICH-HESPANHA, S., ANDRIENKO, N., ANDRIENKO, G., MONTELLO, D.R. (2008): Novel method to measure inference affordance in static small-multiple map displays representing dynamic processes. Cartographic Journal, 45, 3, 201–215. <>
15. FUHRMANN, S., AHONEN-RAINIO, P., EDSALL, R.M., FABRIKANT, S.I., KOUA, E.L., TOBÓN, C., WILSON, S. (2005): Making useful and useable geovisualization: Design and evaluation issues. Exploring Geovisualization, 553–566.
16. FUHRMANN, S., KOMOGORTSEV, O., TAMIR, D. (2009): Investigating Hologram‐Based Route Planning. Transactions in GIS, 13, s1, 177–196. <>
17. GOLDBERG, J.H., KOTVAL, X.P. (1999): Computer interface evaluation using eye movements: methods and constructs. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 24, 6, 631–645. <>
18. GOLDBERG, J.H., STIMSON, M.J., LEWENSTEIN, M., SCOTT, N., WICHANSKY, A.M. (2002): Eye tracking in web search tasks: design implications. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 2002 symposium on Eye tracking research & applications.
19. HEGARTY, M., SMALLMAN, H.S., STULL, A.T., CANHAM, M.S. (2009): Naïve cartography: How intuitions about display configuration can hurt performance. Cartographica: The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization, 44, 3, 171–186. <>
20. CHANG, K.-T., ANTES, J., LENZEN, T. (1985): The effect of experience on reading topographic relief information: Analyses of performance and eye movements. The Cartographic Journal, 22, 2, 88–94. <>
21. IMHOF, E. (2007): Cartographic relief presentation: ESRI, Inc.
22. INCOUL, A., OOMS, K., DE MAEYER, P. (2015). Comparing paper and digital topographic maps using eye tracking Modern Trends in Cartography, 339–356. <>
23. ITTI, L., KOCH, C., NIEBUR, E. (1998): A model of saliency-based visual attention for rapid scene analysis. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis & Machine Intelligence, 11, 1254–1259. <>
24. JACOB, R.J., KARN, K.S. (2003): Eye tracking in human-computer interaction and usability research: Ready to deliver the promises The Mind’s Eye – Cognitive and Applied Aspects of Eye Movement Research, Elsevier, 573–605.
25. JENNY, B., RÄBER, S. (2015): Relief Shading, (16. 6. 2018).
26. KOMOGORTSEV, O.V., JAYARATHNA, S., KOH, D.H., GOWDA, S.M. (2010): Qualitative and quantitative scoring and evaluation of the eye movement classification algorithms. Paper presented at the Symposium on Eye-Tracking Research & Applications (ETRA 2010), Austin, Texas, USA.
27. KUBÍČEK, P., MULIČKOVÁ, E., KONEČNÝ, M., KUČEROVÁ, J. (2011): Flood management and geoinformation support within the emergency cycle (EU example) Environmental Software Systems. Frameworks of eEnvironment (pp. 77–86): Springer.
28. KUBÍČEK, P., ŠAŠINKA, Č., STACHOŇ, Z., HERMAN, L., JUŘÍK, V., URBÁNEK, T., CHMELÍK, J. (2017): Identification of altitude profiles in 3D geovisualizations: the role of interaction and spatial abilities. International Journal of Digital Earth, 1–17.
29. KUBÍČEK, P., ŠAŠINKA, Č., STACHOŇ, Z., ŠTĚRBA, Z., APELTAUER, J., URBÁNEK, T. (2017): Cartographic Design and Usability of Visual Variables for Linear Features. The Cartographic Journal, 54, 1, 91–102. <>
30. KUČERA, M. (2014): Využití open-source nástrojů pro přípravu. průběh a vyhodnocení eye-tracking experimentů. Thesis, Univerzita Palackého, Olomouc.
31. LLOYD, R.E. (2005): Attention on maps. Cartographic Perspectives, 52, 28–57. <>
32. MANLY, B.F. (2006): Randomization, bootstrap and Monte Carlo methods in biology, 70, CRC Press.
33. NÄSÄNEN, R., OJANPÄÄ, H., KOJO, I. (2001): Effect of stimulus contrast on performance and eye movements in visual search. Vision Research, 41, 14, 1817–1824. <>
34. OOMS, K., DE MAEYER, P., FACK, V., VAN ASSCHE, E., WITLOX, F. (2012): Interpreting maps through the eyes of expert and novice users. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 26, 10, 1773–1788. <>
35. OOMS, K., MAEYER, P.D., FACK, V., ASSCHE, E.V., WITLOX, F. (2012b): Investigating the Effectiveness of an Efficient Label Placement Method Using Eye Movement Data. The Cartographic Journal, 49, 3, 234–246. <>
36. ORTAG, F. (2009): Variables of Aesthetics in Maps Cartography and Art, Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1–9.
37. PETROVIČ, D., MAŠERA, P. (2004): Analysis of user’s response on 3D cartographic presentations. Paper presented at the 7th meeting of the ICA Commission on Mountain Cartography.
38. PHILLIPS, R.J., LUCIA, A., SKELTON, N. (1975): Some objective tests of the legibility of relief maps. The Cartographic Journal, 12, 1, 39–46. <>
39. POPELKA, S. (2014): Optimal eye fixation detection settings for cartographic purposes. International Multidisciplinary Scientific GeoConference Surveying Geology and Mining Ecology Management, SGEM, 1, 2, 705–712.
40. POPELKA, S. (2015): Hodnocení 3D vizualizací v GIS s využitím sledování pohybu očí. Univerzita Palackého v Olomouci, Olomouc.
41. POPELKA, S., BRYCHTOVÁ, A. (2013): Eye-tracking study on different perception of 2D and 3D terrain visualisation. The Cartographic Journal, 50, 3, 240–246. <>
42. POTASH, L., FARRELL, J., JEFFREY, T. (1978): A technique for assessing map relief legibility. The Cartographic Journal, 15, 1, 28–35. <>
43. PUTTO, K., KETTUNEN, P., TORNIAINEN, J., KRAUSE, C.M., TIINA SARJAKOSKI, L. (2014): Effects of cartographic elevation visualizations and map-reading tasks on eye movements. The Cartographic Journal, 225–236. <>
44. ROBINSON, A.H., MORRISON, J., MUEHRCKE, P., KIMERLING, A., GUPTILL, S. (1995): Elements of Cartography. New York: John Wiley&Sons.
45. ROHRER, C. (2014). When to Use Which User-Experience Research Methods, (16. 6. 2018).
46. SAVAGE, D.M., WIEBE, E.N., DEVINE, H.A. (2004): Performance of 2d versus 3d topographic representations for different task types. Paper presented at the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting.
47. (2015):, (16. 6. 2018).
48. SCHOBESBERGER, D., PATTERSON, T. (2007): Evaluating the Effectiveness of 2D vs. 3D Trailhead Maps. Paper presented at the 6th ICA Mountain Cartography Workshop, Lenk, Switzerland.
49. STANĚK, K., FRIEDMANNOVÁ, L., KUBÍČEK, P., KONEČNÝ, M. (2010): Selected issues of cartographic communication optimization for emergency centers. International Journal of Digital Earth, 3, 4, 316–339. <>
50. VOßKÜHLER, A., NORDMEIER, V., KUCHINKE, L., JACOBS, A.M. (2008): OGAMA (Open Gaze and Mouse Analyzer): open-source software designed to analyze eye and mouse movements in slideshow study designs. Behavior research methods, 40, 4, 1150–1162. <>
51. WILKENING, J., FABRIKANT, S.I. (2011): How do decision time and realism affect map-based decision making? Spatial Information Theory, Springer, 1–19.
front cover

ISSN 1212-0014 (Print) ISSN 2571-421X (Online)